Does Music Taste Indicate Intelligence: Instrumental Fans Score Higher

CultureSarah Martinez9/10/20252 min read
Does Music Taste Indicate Intelligence: Instrumental Fans Score Higher
## Does Music Taste Indicate Intelligence: What Research Actually Shows --- --- ## Instrumental Music Fans Have Higher IQs **Croatian researchers tested 467 high school students**. The results surprised everyone. Students with **higher intelligence scores** preferred: - **Instrumental music** (no vocals) - **Classical and jazz** - **Ambient/chill electronica** - **Film soundtracks** **The correlation is real**, but tiny. **Personality traits matter more than IQ**. --- --- ## Harvard Debunks the Mozart Effect **The myth**: Listening to classical music makes you smarter. **Harvard's reality check**: - Original "Mozart effect" was just **2.1 IQ points** - Effect lasted only **15 minutes** - **80% of adults** believe this myth despite no evidence - Music lessons showed **2.7 IQ point** gain after a full year (barely significant) > "Music training had no effect on cognitive abilities of young children." > > — **Samuel Mehr**, Harvard researcher **The truth**: Smart people like instrumental music. Music doesn't make them smart. --- --- ## SAT Scores Reveal Genre Rankings **Actual data from student SAT scores:** 1. **Techno**: Highest scores 2. **Classic Rock** 3. **Country** 4. **Rock** 5. **Rap** 6. **R&B** 7. **Classical** (middle, not top) 8. **Alternative** 9. **Reggae** 10. **Pop** 11. **Hip Hop** 12. **Jazz** 13. **Gospel** 14. **Soca**: Lowest scores **Plot twist**: Classical isn't at the top. **Techno listeners scored highest**. --- --- ## Why Smart People Like Wordless Music **Dr. Satoshi Kanazawa's theory**: Intelligence evolved to handle **novel stimuli**. Instrumental music is more "novel" evolutionarily because **humans sang before creating instruments**. **The correlation factors:** - **Novel preference**: High IQ individuals seek new experiences - **Complexity processing**: Instrumental music demands pattern recognition - **Less distraction**: No lyrics means pure musical analysis This mirrors how [introverts excel at deep work through sustained attention](/psychology/why-introverts-excel-at-deep-work-psychology-research-2025), preferring low-stimulation environments that enhance focus. --- --- ## The Bottom Line **Music preference correlates weakly with IQ**. Correlation coefficient usually under **0.1**. **What matters more:** - **Personality traits** (openness to experience) - **Education level** - **Family income** - **Age and gender** **Learning an instrument**: Only **10% IQ boost** according to some studies. However, [cognitive biases make us overestimate these effects](/psychology/your-brain-lies-to-you-cognitive-biases-2025) and create false correlations. This connects to broader research on [how our brains shut down during cognitive overload](/psychology/cognitive-disengagement-multitasking-brain-shutdown), suggesting that music preferences may reflect cognitive processing styles rather than intelligence levels. _Your playlist doesn't define your intelligence, but **instrumental music fans do score slightly higher**._ --- --- ## Sources 1. [PsyPost - Instrumental Music and Intelligence Study](https://www.psypost.org/more-intelligent-individuals-are-more-likely-to-enjoy-instrumental-music-study-finds/) - Croatian research 2. [Harvard Gazette - Muting the Mozart Effect](https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2013/12/muting-the-mozart-effect/) - Debunking myths 3. [SAGE Journals - Intelligence and Music Preferences](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0305735616650991) - Academic research 4. [PMC - Musical Preferences Five-Factor Model](https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4846047/) - Personality correlation study 5. [Classic FM - Learning Instrument IQ Study](https://www.classicfm.com/music-news/learning-musical-instrument-increases-iq-10-percent/) - 10% increase claim